Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Do you believe the human condition cannot be explored through nonfiction? Would you entertain the idea that perhaps it may be possible to explore the human condition deeper and more profoundly through nonfiction than through fiction?

I think it's actually quite insightful to understand that.

Find me a fiction book more profoundly descriptive of the human condition than The Divided Self by RD Laing.



Do you believe the human condition cannot be explored through nonfiction?

No.

Would you entertain the idea that perhaps it may be possible to explore the human condition deeper and more profoundly through nonfiction than through fiction?

It's not a contest.

Find me a fiction book more profoundly descriptive of the human condition than The Divided Self by RD Laing.

You don't believe his book is an exploration of his own personal perspective on reality and meaning?


I believe it is a contest, because we have a limited amount of time on earth. If you could do either A or B and you believe B is better, then why would you do A?

Of course The Divided Self is his exploration of the topic, but it's sold in the nonfiction section.


I believe it is a contest, because we have a limited amount of time on earth.

Well, you have enough time to comment here. Is this really a better exploration of the human condition (or whatever it is you want to achieve through reading) than non-fiction books?

If you could do either A or B and you believe B is better, then why would you do A?

In reality, fiction and non-fiction are not mutually exclusive unless you're obtuse enough to make them so. They're not even clearly distinct in their value or purpose.


Using language like "obtuse" isn't really conducive to conversation. They are different. Yes, there can be facts in a fiction book and fiction in a nonfiction book, but they are categorized differently. Humans need groups to put things in and we put books into groups based on fact and based on imagination.

I'm actually doing about 5 things right now. Playing a poker tournament, chatting with my wife, commenting here, watching an animal documentary on tv, and designing a new feature for my web application.

If I was reading, I'd only be doing one thing.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: