Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Because of racist laws, policies and practices Black people have fewer opportunities from literally before they're born. Studies indicate that poor nutrition and other environmental factors explain the "IQ gap" nearly completely. The remaining points are most likely an issue of bias in the tests themselves. Most white people wouldn't do well in an AAVE based IQ test.

Black people (and other minorities) are being actively discriminated against. In terms of the neighborhoods they live in (white flight), law enforcement (stop and frisk, minimum sentences, racial profiling), employment, housing (mortgage applications) and so on. This active discrimination is an ongoing and constant problem that goes all the way back to apartheid. Black people will do better when white people stop holding them back.

Conflating black culture and active discrimination has racist connotations. For instance appalling Wall Street behavior is not condemned as a failing of white culture, but street crime is erroneously attributed as a failing of black culture. There are a thousand other examples. Black culture: music, food, dance, art, speech are not to blame. No more than white culture is to blame for WW2.

It's part of the racist discourse where environmental factors are described as if they're innate failings of people who are genetically no different from anybody else.

Now I don't believe you're a racist person (you probably don't think group X is inferior to group Y), but the arguments you make have racist connotations for the reasons I gave above.



When white people enter a black neighborhood, it is "gentrification", and it holds blacks back.

When white people move out of a black neighborhood, it is "white flight" and it holds blacks back.

White people! Stay exactly where you are!


Individual people/families (regardless of race) are not to blame for the effect they have on the housing market, even though the consequences are predictable and well documented.

The effects of gentrification and white flight demonstrate how ingrained the bias against black people and other minorities still is.


I don't disagree with you. In fact, everything you wrote is in agreement with my original post. All of those challenges you describe are just some of the factors that make the racial disparity a more difficult problem to solve than the gender disparity.

And yet, my original post is now deleted, so we can go along pretending these problems don't exist.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: