Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I don't have any sexually explicit apps on my phone, I don't care to download any, and I don't even care to have a reddit app (I don't use the site) but the lack of censorship in the android marketplace was always the biggest reason I supported Android. Yes its true you can get apps from other sources but you shouldn't have to. I opposed the need for the amazon app store for example. Anyway this really makes me sad that google feels the need to start filtering for any reason other then malware. I've been a huge android supporter over the past few years, and this in no way is making me get an iphone, but if they continue down on this path I don't know if I'll follow in the future.


> I opposed the need for the amazon app store for example.

I understand what you are saying, but I believe the reasoning applies more directly to other markets (eg, slideme). I don't think that the Amazon App store exists due to restrictive Google policies, but rather due to Amazon's desires to directly enter this market (cf, Kindle Fire).


I've been using smart phones since the treo, and used palm devices since around 1999/2000. Since I've lived through all of that I can really appreciate a single source to get everything, manage updates, etc as long as that source is fair and unbiased. That is why I didn't like when amazon launched their own store for android apps. It added a second store you had to run to update apps, and segregated the market, etc. If google keeps heading down this path though I will support a open 3rd party marketplace.


Thankfully though, you can still always download the app directly from the creator without needing to do anything complicated to your device.


But then you lose things like the ability for it to auto update when the marketplace err play store detects a new version.

Also I was doing some research on the app creator and whats funny is it looks like a couple years ago google even sent the creator a free nexus one for making the first version of this app. lol.


> But then you lose things like the ability for it to auto update

Not at all: http://f-droid.org/


>the lack of censorship in the android marketplace was always the biggest reason I supported Android //

So you support Android only as far as they allow the undesired exposure of users to hardcore porn or shock imagery? That seems a very strange line to take.


Speaking for myself, yes, I support Android as long as they allow hardcore porn or shock imagery.

This is not because I want to watch those things (although I do occasionally), but because otherwise it means I'm losing the freedom to do that. And first it's porn, but what's next? Political oppinions? Google's competition?

I'm so dissapointed.


They have content filtering settings in the market.

[x] everyone

[x] low maturity

[x] medium maturity

[x] high maturity

[x] show all apps

With settings like that where the device owner can pick what they want to see why block anything.


So lack of censorship isn't the reason that you love Android it is instead categorisation of censored material??

>why block anything //

Presumably to retain users and keep inside the relevant laws.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: