Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

A good ranked choice system like Schulze, avoids that issue.

You can give multiple people the same rank, to express no preference between them. So you could have two or more choices you don't want to express an opinion between both marked 1, then perhaps the lesser but still acceptable candidates marked 2, the unacceptable candidates as 3, and extremely unacceptable candidates as 4.

Meanwhile, somebody else can come along and rank all the candidates with a unique number if they prefer.

In Schulze, all the numbering is doing is expressing who you would pick in a one-on-one race any pair of candidates.

Ranking candidates the same (tied), simply means you would have left that question blank on a traditional FPTP ballot because you don't care which of the two wins, either because you find them equally good/bad or you feel they sufficiently close that you would prefer to let those who care more decide.

For example, I don't own a home, or have kids, so i will usually leave school property tax levy questions blank. I may have some super slight preference one way or another, but I'm mostly unaffected, so I will let those who actually care about this decide.



Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: